Pantheistic Theosophy Is Irreconcilable with Roman Catholicism

Helena Petrovna Blavatsky and Abbe Roca · Blavatsky Speaks Series · 90 pages

Ninety pages, and the most substantial exchange in the section — a controversy conducted at length with a named opponent who is given as much space as she takes. Abbe Roca was a French canon who believed the esotericism of Christian dogma could be reconciled with theosophical teaching, and Boris de Zirkoff's preamble sets out how the dispute arose. Roca's own case is printed first, in two numbered sections, with her note appended.

Her refutation turns on a single doctrine, the Word made flesh. Christian texts, she argues, are allegories pointing to the archaic mysteries of the cycle of initiation and keys to a once universal mystery-language, and read esoterically they reveal their fundamental identity with the same universal truths held elsewhere. But by imposing the Word made flesh as dogma — a unique incarnation at one moment in history — the Latin Church places itself diametrically against the tenets of Eastern occultism, and maintains an abyss between East and West so long as neither yields. The length is what makes the document valuable: both positions are stated fully enough that a reader can judge the disagreement rather than take it on trust.

Read the full text (PDF, 2.5 MB, 90 pages)